International Journal of Energy Engineering          
International Journal of Energy Engineering(IJEE)
Frequency: Yearly
Editor-in-Chief: Prof. Sri Bandyopadhyay(Australia)
Citizen Involvement and the Role of Experts in Finnish Energy Policy-Making
Full Paper(PDF, 55KB)
Finnish energy policy is characterized by special characteristics in international comparison. Even though the construction of nuclear power plants had almost ceased abroad, here the construction of a new plant was licensed by Parliament in 2002, which was followed by licenses for two reactors in 2010. The purpose of the present study is to discuss, whether Finn’s attitudes on energy-policy have engendered conditions for “big” energy policy decisions which in most countries have been very difficult to make. The empirical analysis of the present study is composed of three parts: citizens’ views on their possibilities to influence energy policy-making through representative democracy and political consumerism; their trust in the energy information produced by various actors, and their normative views on the role of experts and political decision-makers in energy policy-making. The study is based on a postal survey conducted among a random sample (N=4000) representing 18-75-year old Finns in 2007. Finns prefer experts rather than politicians to be in charge of energy policy-making. Research institutions representing scientific expertise were seen by the citizenry the most reliable sources of energy information. On the other hand, individual consumption choices were rated to be more useful than, for instance, voting in elections or contacts with MPs, contacts with authorities and energy-producing companies. Hence, it is evident that the Finnish attitudinal climate has created a fruitful soil for decisions concerning energy policy, especially nuclear power.
Keywords:Energy Policy; Power; Expertise; Political Consumerism; Finland
Author: Ilkka Ruostetsaari1
1.School of Management, FI-33014 University of Tampere, Finland
  1. I. Ruostetsaari,, “Changing Regulation and Governance of Finnish Energy Policy-Making: New Rules but Old Elites?” Review of Policy Research, Volume 27, Number 3, pp. 273-297, 2010.
  2. T. Litmanen and M. Kojo, “Not Excluding Nuclear Power: the Dynamics and Stability of Nuclear Power Policy Arrangements in Finland. Journal of Integrative Environmental Sciences 8:3, 171-194, 2011.
  3. I. Ruostetsaari, Energiapolitiikan määräytyminen. Julkisten, kollektiivisten ja markkinaperusteisten toimijoiden asema Suomen energiasektorin politiikkaverkostossa. Acta Universitatis Tamperensis, Ser. A, Vol. 278. Tampereen yliopisto, Tampere, 1989.
  4. H. Paloheimo, ”Asenteet poliittisia instituutioita ja toimijoita kohtaan”, in S. Borg (ed.), Suomen demokratiaindikaattorit. Julkaisu nr 1. Helsinki: oikeusministeriö, 128-53, 2006.
  5. L. Karvonen and H. Paloheimo, ”Demokratian näkymiä Suomessa”, in Paloheimo, Heikki (ed.), Vaalit ja demokratia Suomessa, 290-304, Helsinki: WSOY, 2005.
  6. M. Siisiäinen and T. Kankainen, “Järjestötoiminnan kehitys ja tulevaisuudennäkymät Suomessa”, in Suomalaiset osallistujina. Oikeusministeriön julkaisuja 5. Helsinki: Oikeusministeriö, 91-138, 2009.
  7. L. Stranius, “Epämuodollinen kansalaistoiminta – järjestötoiminnasta kevytaktivismiin”, in Suomalaiset osallistujina. Oikeusministeriön julkaisuja 5. Helsinki: Oikeusministeriö, 139-169, 2009.
  8. Science Barometer. Helsinki: Tieteen tiedotus ry, 2007.
  9. M. Rask, “Expanding Expertise in Science and Technology Decision Making”. Futura, Vol.27, Nr. 3, 76-81, 2008.
  10. J.E. Chubb, Interest Groups and the Bureaucracy. The Politics of Energy. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1983.
  11. T. Litmanen, I. Ruostetsaari, M. Salo, M. Kari and M. Kojo, Energiapoliittinen vallankäyttö Suomessa –kansalaisten näkemyksiä energiapolitiikan hallinnasta ja vallankäytöstä. Manuscript. University of Jyväskylä, Department of Social Sciences and Philosophy, 2009.
  12. I. Ruostetsaari, “Governance and Political Consumerism in Finnish Energy Policy-Making”. Energy Policy 37, 102-110, 2009.
  13. I. Ruostetsaari, “Citizens, Politicians and Experts in Finnish Energy Policy-Making”. Energy &Environment Vol. 21, No. 3, 203-222, 2010.
  14. M. Rask, Expansion of Expertise in the Governance of Science and Technology. Helsinki: National Research Centre, 2008.
  15. S. Kuitunen and K. Lähteenmäki-Smith, “Eliittien pelikenttä? Teknologiapolitiikan malli ja periaatteet Suomessa”. Politiikka 48:2: 99-114, 2006.
  16. J. Peterson and M. Sharp, Technology Policy in the European Union. New York: MacMillan, 2001.
  17. T. Lemola, “Tiede- ja teknologiapolitiikan muutostarpeet”, in T. Lemola and P. Honkanen (eds.), Innovaatiopolitiikka. Kenen hyväksi, keiden ehdoilla? Helsinki: Gaudeamus, 290-303, 2004.
  18. D. Rucht, “The Impact of Anti-Nuclear Power Movements in International Comparison”, in M. Bauer (ed.), Resistance to New Technology. Nuclear Power, Information technology and Biotechnology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 277-292, 1997.
  19. F. Fischer, Technocracy and the Politics of Expertise. London: Sage, 1990.
  20. P. Hokkanen, Kansalaisosallistuminen ympäristövaikutusten arviointimenettelyssä. Acta Universitatis Tamperensis 1285. Tampere: Tampere University Press, 2007.
  21. R. Hague and M. Harrop, Comparative Government and Politics. An Introduction. 5th ed. Palgrave, Basingstoke, 2001.
  22. P. Pesonen and O. Riihinen, Dynamic Finland. The Political System and the Welfare State. Finnish Literature Society, Helsinki, 2001.
  23. Å. Bentsson and K. Grönlund, Kimmo (2005). Muu poliittinen osallistuminen, in: H. Paloheimo (ed.), Vaalit ja demokratia Suomessa. WSOY, Helsinki. pp. 147-168, 2005.
  24. M. Micheletti, Political Virtue and Shopping. Inidividuals, Consumerism, and Collective Action. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003.
  25. S. Borg and M. Moring, “Vaalikampanja”, in H. Paloheimo (ed.), Vaalit ja demokratia Suomessa. Helsinki: WSOY, 47-72, 2005.
  26. I. Ruostetsaari, Energiapolitiikka käännekohdassa. Järjestöt ja yritykset vaikuttajina vapautuvilla energiamarkkinoilla. Politiikan tutkimuksen laitos. Research reports 8. Tampere: Tampereen yliopisto, 1998.
  27. M. Siisiäinen, “Uusien ja vanhojen liikkeiden keinovalikoimat”, in: K. Ilmonen and M. Siisiäinen, (eds.), Uudet ja vanhat liikkeet, Vastapaino, Tampere, 219-243, 1998.
  28. P. Rosanvallon, Vastademokratia. Politiikka epäluulon aikakaudella (original publication: La contre-démocratie. La politique à l’âge de la defiance). Tampere: Vastapaino, 2008.
  29. Energy Attitudes, Research report 25.4.2008. Finnish Energy Industries, Helsinki. Consulted Aug. 2008: / 07.htms, 2007.
  30. K. Elo and L. Rapeli, Suomalaisten politiikkatietämys. Julkaisu nr 6. Helsinki: oikeusministeriö, 2008.
  31. Å. Bengtsson and M. Mattila, Mikko (2009). “Suoran demokratian ja häivedemokratian kannatus Suomessa”, in S. Borg and H. Paloheimo (eds.), Vaalit yleisödemokratiassa. Tampere: Tampere University Press, 303-324, 2009.
  32. J. R. Hibbing and E. Theiss-Morse, Stealth Democracy. Americans’ Beliefs about How Government Should Work. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002.
  33. Annual Report to the European Commission: Finland, Helsinki: Energy Market Authority, 2007.